In boardrooms around the world, executives invest millions in team-building retreats and quirky office perks while shareholders ask just one thing: “Show us the results.”
It’s the classic tension of modern business. On one side, the “wellness” movement is pushing for psychological safety and connection. On the other hand, the cold, hard reality of the profit and loss.
When ruthless, high-performing giants dominate the market while “community-first” businesses struggle to keep the lights on, it’s time for an uncomfortable conversation.
Welcome back to Edge Case, where we take controversial industry beliefs and debate them properly. No panel discussions where everyone agrees. No softball questions. Just structured debate with real data and genuine curiosity.
The Format
Tameka Smith and Sophie Lyon flipped a coin to determine who would pick the debate topic and who would choose their side — affirmative or negative.
The goal? Not to declare winners, but to explore every angle of an issue the industry usually tiptoes around.
The Topic
“That company culture is overrated: Results are all that matter.”
How Edge Case Works
Six structured rounds:
- Opening statements (90 seconds each)
- Cross-examination
- Evidence and data presentation
- Direct rebuttals
- Final arguments
- Truth reveal (where they share what they actually believe)
Key Moments from the Debate
The Affirmative (Results First) came out swinging: Tameka Smith, usually a staunch advocate for culture, was forced to argue the opposite. She opened with a brutal truth:
“Culture doesn’t keep the lights on. Results do. The reality is, without results, there is no company left to have a culture.”
The argument? You can preach “community first” all you want, but you cannot celebrate teamwork in a business that has gone bust. Tameka argued that winning creates pride, not the other way around.
The metaphor:
“Culture is the atmosphere. Results are the oxygen. And without oxygen, culture cannot breathe.”
The Evidence: She pointed to global streaming giants who openly prioritise performance over comfort. Their policy? “Adequate performance gets a generous severance package.” The result? Billions in revenue and market dominance. They didn’t become world leaders because of ping-pong tables; they built world-class cultures because they delivered world-class results.
The Counter-Argument (Culture First) Sophie Lyon hit back, arguing that a results-only focus is a ticking time bomb.
“If you say that results are more important than culture, then that actually becomes your culture. People just constantly chase the next deal.”
The Reality: Sophie argued that organisations fueled solely by revenue targets eventually rot from the inside due to distrust and lack of alignment. Short-term results might look good, but they are fragile.
The Data:
- Toxic cultures have a 48% higher turnover rate.
- 65% of employees in a recent study said they would prefer to take lower pay than work within a toxic structure.
- Replacing staff is one of the single biggest costs to an agency’s bottom line.
The Truth Reveal
At the 15-minute mark, both debaters dropped their assigned positions to discuss what they really believe.
Tameka’s Shift: Interestingly, Tameka admitted that preparing for this debate changed her perspective. While she has always credited her business success to culture, she realised she couldn’t have built that culture without the wins.
“I honestly believe my business success was about the culture I created… but there’s no way I would have achieved that without the results. When the results slipped, so did the culture. Finger-pointing started. Survival mode kicked in.”
Sophie’s Consensus: Sophie agreed, noting that there is a “trap” in modern leadership where we confuse culture with perks.
“What have you got if you don’t have results? A whole lot of people sitting around in beanbags eating Twisties. That’s not going to keep the lights on.”
The Verdict: Both leaders agreed that the industry often confuses “pizza parties” with accountability. The real answer isn’t one or the other—it’s about timeline.
- In a crisis? You need results to survive.
- In growth mode? You need culture to scale.
- The advice: If you have $50k to spend, don’t book a retreat if you don’t have a CRM that works. Fix the results engine first, then build the culture on top of that success.
Why This Matters
This episode cuts to the heart of a struggle every agency owner faces: The “Give, Give, Give” Trap.
As Gen Z makes up a larger portion of the workforce, the demand for “good culture” is higher than ever. But as Tameka and Sophie discussed, leaders must set clear expectations. Culture isn’t about making work “fun” every day; it’s about shared accountability and the pride that comes from winning together.
Have Your Say
Is company culture overrated? Vote in Monday’s Edition of The Brief
Listen/Watch now
- YouTube
- Spotify
- Apple Podcasts
- and on your favourite podcast player!
Connect with Tameka Smith
- Website: www.tamekasmith.com.au
- LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/tameka-smith-084142104
- Instagram: @tamekasmith2
- Facebook: tamekasmithconsultingAU
Connect with Sophie Lyon
- Real+: realplus.com.au
- LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/sophielyon
Elite Agent is the definitive platform for ambitious agents and industry players. Thought Leaders is the weekly show where top operators reveal how they’re reinventing real estate. AI-Powered Agents is your playbook for deploying AI that sells homes and scales teams.
