Australian buyers are increasingly prepared to compromise on the home itself to secure the right neighbourhood, with new research revealing 67 per cent would accept a less-than-ideal property if the surrounding area met their expectations.
The finding, from Cotality’s new global report The Social Network, places Australia ahead of the four other markets surveyed, with the combined international figure sitting at 59 per cent.
The research, which surveyed homebuyers across Australia, New Zealand, the UK, US and Canada, suggests that while affordability pressures are forcing buyers to reassess their expectations, the characteristics of a neighbourhood remain a significant consideration.
The findings highlight the importance of selling more than the property itself, with local knowledge, neighbourhood conditions and lifestyle considerations playing an increasingly important role in helping buyers make decisions.
Buyers will compromise on the house, but not their surroundings
The research found that price, feeling safe and privacy or anonymity were equally important to Australian buyers, with each nominated by 91 per cent of respondents.
Noise levels at different times of day followed closely at 90 per cent, while 87 per cent considered recorded crime levels important when choosing where to live.
Cotality Senior Director of Industry Solutions Tom Coad said the results demonstrated that buyers were becoming more selective about where they were prepared to compromise.
“With affordability continuing to challenge Australian buyers, many are having to reconsider their property priorities. However, our research shows those compromises have limits. Buyers may accept a less ideal home, but they are far less willing to compromise on feeling safe and comfortable in the surrounding neighbourhood.
“This has implications for how we understand property demand and value. A home’s appeal cannot be considered in isolation from its surroundings. Factors such as safety, privacy and noise all contribute to a neighbourhood’s desirability and, ultimately, where buyers choose to invest.”
The findings build on previous Cotality research showing 75 per cent of Australians were willing to reduce lifestyle spending to afford a home.
Together, the studies suggest buyers are making financial and property-related sacrifices, but are less prepared to compromise on the environment in which they will live.
Community matters, but privacy still comes first
While buyers are placing considerable value on their surroundings, the research also reveals a distinction between wanting to belong to a neighbourhood and wanting to be actively involved in its community.
Some 69 per cent of Australian respondents said they would pay extra for a sense of belonging, yet only 15 per cent wanted the deepest level of community involvement.
Privacy remained a priority for 91 per cent of respondents.
Generational differences were also evident across the five countries surveyed.
Millennials were more willing than Baby Boomers to pay extra for a sense of belonging, at 74 per cent compared with 58 per cent.
Younger buyers were also more prepared to accept a less ideal property to secure that sense of belonging, with 66 per cent of Millennials willing to compromise compared with 43 per cent of Baby Boomers.
However, shared social and cultural characteristics were not among the strongest priorities for Australian buyers.
Only 10 per cent included similar social, cultural or lifestyle mindsets among their three most important neighbourhood considerations, while just 7 per cent selected political or religious characteristics.
The findings suggest that buyers’ expectations of a desirable neighbourhood are shaped more by practical considerations such as safety, privacy and comfort than by having similar backgrounds or beliefs to those living nearby.
Why local knowledge could give agents an advantage
One of the clearest implications for agents is the importance buyers place on their own experiences when assessing a neighbourhood.
The report found 78 per cent of Australian respondents considered what they saw, heard or learned during a neighbourhood visit more important than official statistics, compared with 73 per cent globally.
However, 71 per cent of this group were concerned about discovering negative aspects of an area after moving in.
The findings point to an opportunity for agents to provide buyers with a more complete understanding of a neighbourhood beyond what they might discover during a single inspection.
Information about local amenities, traffic conditions, noise and the surrounding environment could help buyers assess whether a property suits their longer-term needs.
Mr Coad said understanding the different ways buyers define their ideal neighbourhood was becoming increasingly important.
“There is no single formula for what makes a neighbourhood feel right. For some, it’s getting to know their neighbours and being part of the community; for others, it’s having the privacy and space to enjoy their own lifestyle,” said Mr Coad.
“With high prices and strong competition narrowing buyers’ choices, getting the location right matters more than ever. A viewing only reveals so much, so agents who share local insights can help buyers see the full picture before they commit.”
The research reinforces the value of understanding what matters most to individual buyers rather than assuming that property features alone will determine their decision.
Buyers may be willing to compromise on aspects of the property itself, but the surrounding neighbourhood could ultimately determine whether they proceed with a purchase.