The NSW Government has moved to put its controversial underquoting reforms on hold for up to 12 months, following concerns that the new rules could prevent agents from adjusting advertised prices in a declining property market.

The changes were scheduled to take effect on Tuesday, 17 November, but Premier Chris Minns intervened after acknowledging that restrictions on lowering advertised prices could disadvantage both buyers and sellers when market conditions change.

Under the proposed requirements, agents would have been prevented from advertising a property below the value of a written offer rejected by the seller solely because the amount offered was too low, even if the property’s market value subsequently declined.

Benson Auctions Director and Auctioneer Stu Benson, who had publicly raised concerns about the legislation before the government’s intervention, said the decision was welcome but questioned why it had taken so long.

“I think it’s a shame that it took this long. It got to the eleventh hour,” Mr Benson said.

He said agents had faced considerable pressure preparing for the changes, including modifying systems and procedures and attending training sessions and webinars.

“The industry by and large in New South Wales have been calling for this to be looked at for the better part of a year,” he said.

Mr Benson believes the government has now recognised the potential consequences of restricting sellers’ ability to respond to falling prices.

“It looks like the Minns Government, and Chris Minns in particular, has looked at this through a common-sense lens,” he said.

He argued that preventing vendors from adjusting their advertised prices to reflect current conditions could cost them money at a time when many were already facing financial pressure.

Buyers deserve transparency, but sellers need protection too

Before the government’s decision, Mr Benson published a Facebook video outlining his concerns about the legislation, while making it clear he supported greater transparency around property prices.

“I’m an auctioneer. I’m all for price guiding. I think it’s fantastic consumer advocacy to make sure that buyers aren’t wasting their time,” he said.

Mr Benson said realistic price guides could prevent buyers from becoming financially and emotionally invested in properties they had little chance of purchasing.

“They’re emotionally or financially getting invested in properties that they can probably never afford, so they shouldn’t be wasting their time,” he said.

He said that included spending money on building and pest inspections, solicitors and conveyancing, only to discover on auction day that the property was beyond their budget.

He also believed accurate guides would improve auction campaigns by attracting buyers who were genuinely in a position to compete.

“If you see a guide, you should theoretically, therefore, be able to reach the seller’s expectation with a bit of a stretch, a bit of competition, or an offer that is presented on auction day that is cash and unconditional,” he said.

While competition could still drive a property beyond its advertised guide, Mr Benson argued buyers should at least have a realistic opportunity to purchase.

“You should have a bona fide chance of purchasing the property if the guide aligns with your budget,” he said.

However, he believed the proposed reforms overlooked the financial responsibilities and changing circumstances of the person selling the property.

“What you’ve forgotten in the entire equation is that the seller is also a consumer. The seller has a lot of risk,” Mr Benson said.

“They have a property that they have a mortgage on more often than not, and with that comes inherent risk.”

He said sellers could be dealing with mortgage repayments, changing interest rates and financial commitments that did not disappear simply because their property was on the market.

“They’ve got obligations, and they’ve got changing interest rates. They have needs, wants, and things that we should be looking after as well,” he said.

“I genuinely believe that the vendor as a consumer has been completely forgotten.”

How a rejected offer could leave sellers stuck

To illustrate his concerns, Mr Benson outlined a hypothetical auction campaign involving a property initially advertised with a $1.9 million guide.

In his example, a buyer submitted an unconditional written offer of $1.96 million early in the campaign, which the vendor rejected because they believed a higher price might be achieved at auction.

The seller had received strong interest at the first open home and was prepared to accept the risk of continuing the campaign.

Under the proposed rules, the rejected offer would establish a minimum advertised price of $1.96 million, assuming the offer was rejected solely because the amount was too low.

But Mr Benson questioned what would happen if market conditions changed before auction day.

In his example, an interest rate increase reduced buyers’ borrowing capacity, inspections slowed and the original buyer purchased another property.

The vendor’s circumstances also changed, leaving them willing to consider offers closer to $1.9 million.

Despite the agent and seller agreeing that a lower price was now appropriate, the proposed restrictions would prevent the advertised guide from being reduced below the earlier rejected offer.

“I still cannot move the price guide towards the seller’s expectation and towards the buyer pool who has shifted because of the interest rate rises and serviceability,” Mr Benson said.

He argued that the restriction could prevent a property from appearing in online searches conducted by buyers whose budgets aligned with the vendor’s revised expectations.

“We are handcuffing sellers in a marketplace where we are purporting to be all about consumer advocacy, and we’re forgetting that a seller is a consumer as well,” he said.

Mr Benson said he was not advocating for agents to advertise misleading prices, but rather for the ability to make transparent, documented adjustments when circumstances genuinely changed.

“If the seller’s situation changes, we should be able to go back out with full transparency and tell every single person we’re going to revert back to a $1,900,000 guide on this property,” he said.

“We’re not doing anything deceptive. We are doing what the vendor wants us to do.”

He said any revised guide should be properly documented, supported by evidence and agreed to by the seller.

“You cannot hold a vendor to a price that doesn’t exist anymore, particularly if their circumstances have changed,” he said.

Eleventh-hour decision leaves agents seeking clarity

The government’s intervention comes amid continued weakness in Sydney’s property market.

According to Cotality figures reported by the ABC, Sydney house prices have fallen close to 9.7 per cent since the end of January, while unit prices have declined 5.2 per cent.

Mr Minns acknowledged on Monday that the proposed restrictions could create unintended consequences in a falling market.

“It’s not the seller or the agent’s fault if the price of real estate is dropping,” the Premier told the ABC.

“The legislation, at least intuitively, believed that the prices would always rise. Well, that may not be the case.”

Real Estate Institute of NSW CEO Tim McKibbin also raised concerns about the impact on buyers and sellers, arguing that the restrictions could prevent advertised prices from reflecting a property’s changed circumstances.

“It misleads and disadvantages those purchasers and it certainly disadvantages the vendor,” Mr McKibbin told the ABC.

He said the industry had previously warned the government about the potential consequences.

“We made clear that this wouldn’t work out in the market [and] we were ignored,” he said.

While Mr Benson welcomed the government’s decision to reconsider the changes, he said the way the announcement had been communicated left agents uncertain about their immediate obligations.

“The communication is still extremely lacking,” he said.

He said agents had largely learned about the decision through media reporting rather than receiving direct communication from the government or regulatory authorities.

Mr Benson said the REINSW had been taking the initiative to provide information to members based on what it had been able to establish.

The timing was particularly frustrating, he said, given the amount of work agents had already undertaken to prepare for the new requirements.

According to the ABC, the government is expected to use a regulation to delay the changes rather than seek further legislative amendments before parliament rises for the year.

The reported pause includes the proposed requirement to advertise a selling price or price range, as well as increased penalties for underquoting of up to $110,000 or three times an agent’s commission, whichever is greater.

However, underquoting remains illegal under existing NSW legislation, and agents must continue to comply with applicable pricing and advertising obligations.

Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong acknowledged that the legislation had been passed under different economic conditions.

“People are already doing it tough, and the last thing we want is for laws designed to protect home buyers to inadvertently make it harder for them to buy a home,” Mr Chanthivong told the ABC.