Own your real estate data: agency control and AI impact

Real estate agents spend years building relationships, growing databases and developing an understanding of their local markets.

Yet much of the information generated through those relationships is increasingly being managed through platforms and technology providers outside their businesses. For many agencies, it’s simply how the industry operates.

Listings go onto the major portals, enquiries arrive through third-party systems and customer information is spread across multiple software products. But as artificial intelligence changes how buyers search for property and technology companies expand their role in the transaction, questions are emerging about how much control agencies actually retain over their own data.

DiJones CEO Dean Mackie believes it’s a conversation the industry can no longer afford to overlook.

His concern isn’t that agents should stop using the major property portals – in fact, he acknowledges the enormous value they provide in reaching buyers.

“I don’t want to be anti-portal in this conversation. In fact, we’re not,” Dean says.

“We’re very much a business that sees portals having incredible reach that we can’t achieve on our own, and they’re not going anywhere.”

The issue, he believes, is finding a better balance between the services agencies purchase and the information they retain control over.

“I think owning your own data going forward will become even more important because I can’t see how the industry is going to have any level of negotiation power if we’re completely dependent on the portals for our data and operations,” he says.

“We want to partner with the portals, but we want to be able to do it on the basis that it’s not from complete data and operational dependency.”

The hidden value in everyday agency data

Most agents understand the importance of their database. It’s where their future listings, buyers, landlords and referral opportunities often come from.

But Dean believes the industry needs to think more broadly about what customer data actually includes.

Every property enquiry, inspection, brochure download and interaction with an agency’s website can provide information about what a buyer wants and where they might be in their property journey.

The challenge is that these interactions frequently happen across different systems, leaving agencies with an incomplete picture of their customers.

Dean says the traditional approach to agency websites has contributed to the problem.

“What’s happened over time is that agencies have often had a website that’s just a property brochure, and often a low-quality one that doesn’t do anything,” he says.

“When they’re advertising all of their listings through a portal, they’re thinking, why would I bother investing in a technology platform? I just put it up on REA or Domain, turn up at the open home on Saturday, and people will turn up.”

While that model has delivered results, he believes it has also reduced the incentive for agencies to invest in their own digital infrastructure. And as portals introduce additional services covering prospecting, customer management and other parts of the transaction, agencies need to consider where their information is being stored and how easily they can access it.

“Bit by bit, they’re having the agent provide all of their content and information to them, as well as using all their operating systems,” Dean says.

“When an agency relies entirely on external platforms for its content, operating systems, and buyer matching, it stops operating like an independent business and starts operating like a contractor on someone else’s infrastructure.

“We want our agents to build real equity in their own relationships and client intelligence.”

He describes the potential outcome as a bundled-service trap, where convenience can make it increasingly difficult for an agency to operate independently.

For Dean, owning data means more than having a list of names and phone numbers stored in a CRM.

It means having the systems, permissions and processes to understand customer activity and use that information to provide a better service.

Why AI is changing the conversation

The growing influence of artificial intelligence adds another dimension to the issue.

As consumers increasingly use AI-powered tools to research suburbs, compare properties and find information, the way online content is discovered and attributed is changing.

Dean believes agencies need to consider how their own websites and property information fit into that environment.

“If you don’t own your content and your data, and you’re not publishing it first, effectively whoever is aggregating it becomes the authority source,” he says.

“When there’s an AI search done, or any sort of search, it’s bypassing the agent and the agency and going straight into the portal.”

While publishing information first does not automatically guarantee priority in AI-generated results, maintaining authoritative property content on an agency’s own website can form part of a broader digital strategy.

“It’s why we’ve built an exclusive preview window into our process. Before a property hits the public portals, it lives on our platform first, supported by targeted digital campaigns through our Magnifi engine.

“That gives us first party publishing authority for AI search, builds a retargetable buyer audience that belongs to us and our client, and frequently lets us match one of that 86 per cent of existing ecosystem buyers before the vendor spends a dollar on major portal campaigns.”

The issue is also attracting attention internationally; in the United States, disagreements involving major brokerages and property portals have highlighted tensions over listing distribution and control of property information.

Dean points to Compass as an example of a brokerage challenging established listing distribution practices.

He believes Australian agencies should pay attention to those developments, particularly as more technology providers seek to offer services covering multiple stages of the property transaction.

“I think for a balanced industry, and for the longevity of all parties involved, there needs to be a bit of rebalancing of how that all works,” he says.

What owning your data looks like in practice

One of the clearest examples is how agencies manage buyers who are already known to their business.

Traditionally, a buyer who misses out on a property may return to a major portal to begin searching again, even though the agency already knows their requirements and may have another suitable listing.

Dean believes agencies should be better equipped to maintain that relationship.

At DiJones, the business has invested in connecting its website, CRM and customer information to help identify buyer activity and match people with relevant properties.

“When you start combining that with third-party information, you can start connecting the dots on what people’s intent signals are,” he says.

“If they opt in and supply information, it allows us to match them back to specific suburbs, properties and agents.”

Dean says approximately 86 per cent of buyers who have purchased through the agency have already been within its customer ecosystem for at least six months.

That figure, which he says has fluctuated between approximately 85 and 89 per cent, has influenced how the business approaches buyer engagement and property marketing.

“Why would I send them back to the front of the queue if we already know who they are?” he asks.

“We know dynamically what they’re looking at, and we can surface properties they’re looking to buy.”

The principle is relevant well beyond one agency. If an agent already knows a buyer’s budget, preferred location and property requirements, there may be opportunities to reconnect them with suitable listings without waiting for another enquiry.

For smaller agencies, that could begin with ensuring buyer enquiries are consistently recorded, customer requirements are updated and agents are using the information already available in their CRM.

The objective isn’t necessarily to replace existing technology, but to make sure it is working for the agency rather than leaving valuable information scattered across disconnected systems.

Where smaller agencies can begin

Of course, there is a significant difference between recognising the importance of data ownership and having the resources to do something about it.

Smaller independent agencies may not have dedicated technology teams, substantial development budgets or the time to investigate how every system works.

Dean acknowledges that reality.

“If you’re a small independent operator, you’re running around trying to make sure your business is operating and trying to do a thousand things at once,” he says.

For smaller independent principals, the challenge is finding ways to access sophisticated technology without having to build and manage it themselves.

Franchise businesses can face similar challenges, particularly where offices operate independently and use different systems despite sharing the same brand.

He believes one of the industry’s biggest mistakes has been attempting to solve technology problems by continually adding new software.

He describes it as a Christmas tree of technology, where agencies purchase individual products that appear to solve immediate problems but don’t necessarily communicate with one another.

“People try to take the fast route because they don’t understand it. They plug in this whole Christmas tree of technology to get there as quickly as they can at the lowest cost,” he says.

“But all it does is drive up subscription costs. It looks okay on the surface, but nothing really talks in the background. You’re still giving third-party providers all of your data, and if they turn off tomorrow, or you turn them off tomorrow, you lose it all.”

Instead of focusing on the next software product, he believes principals should first understand the systems they already have. Where does the agency’s customer information sit?

Can it be exported if the business changes providers? Does information entered into one system flow into another? And can agents easily identify the buyers and sellers already engaging with the business?

Dean also believes the industry could benefit from greater collaboration, with agencies exploring shared technology infrastructure while maintaining control of their individual customer information.

“Why aren’t we all working together? That’s actually why we built the DiJones Marketplace. Most independent principals and top performing agents shouldn’t have to become software architects or burn millions building custom data lakes.

“They should be able to plug into a proven operating platform that handles the heavy lifting, from AEO and buyer matching to back end compliance, while they stay focused on their clients and their local market.”

But even when agencies invest in better systems, getting agents to change how they work can be difficult.

“Even if they’ve got all this technology and infrastructure in place, teaching agents to go through the change is where the heavy lifting happens,” Dean says.

“We had some real issues as we went through that with more than 20 offices. We were trying to teach our agents why this was important and how it worked. There was a lot of change management fatigue.”

“What we realised is that agents aren’t stubborn, they’re protecting their pipeline.

“If a new system slows them down, it threatens their income. So we stopped doing massive, disruptive rollouts and shifted to 14 day sprints driven by agent feedback through our internal AI. Now, the tech removes friction from their day rather than adding to it.”

In a softer property market, convincing agents to spend time learning new systems can be even harder. Dean believes the experience highlights why technology changes need to be practical, responsive to agent feedback and designed to support the work agents are already doing.

For agents, the issue ultimately comes back to the relationships they have worked to establish. Technology can help attract enquiries, manage transactions and identify opportunities, but it is the agency that builds trust with buyers, sellers and landlords.

Dean believes the industry needs to ensure the information generated through those relationships continues to benefit the businesses and customers involved.

“The portals will always be a vital part of the marketing mix, but the agencies that thrive over the next decade will be the ones that own their customer relationships end to end, that uses technology to elevate the advisor, not sit between the advisor and their client.”